banner
President's Report.
 
Hello Rotarians
 
It has been a quiet week and we have kept our money in our wallet as Matt Northeast didn't have his cert running!
 
The joint meeting is on Thursday. Please reply to Ian Harper if you are intending to go.
 
It was interesting to hear Louise talk on her time as an exchange student 50 years ago.
 
I am in Adelaide this week so Paul will take the reigns for the meeting.
Remember we are moving into the 19th century with our footy tipping. You need the AFL app on your phone to do your tips. Let Verto, Tony D or myself know if you haven't been invited yet.
 
Our Bonomatic 2000 has made the district newsletter! Word is getting around!*
 
Colleen D'offay has invited us to attend DIK for a tour. Im thinking a road trip in a couple of cars if there is interest. Please let me know if you are interested. 
 
See you all next week when we have Paul Brophy talking on the Fr Bob Maguire foundation.
 
Regards
 
Bono
 
 
 
*The world is truly full of surprises - Ed.
 
 
 
 
 
Upcoming Events
 
5th March - Proposed joint meeting of Rotary Clubs.
 
11th March - Father Bob McGuire guest speaker.
Club Information
Welcome to our Club!
Warrnambool Central
Imagine Rotary
Wednesdays at 1:00 PM
Warrnambool Bowls Club
75 Timor St
Warrnambool, VIC 3280
Australia
Phone:
0493 467 248
Please join us for lunch at the Warrnambool Bowls Club.
District Site Icon
District Site
Venue Map
Venue Map
Executives & Directors
President
 
President Elect
 
Secretary
 
Treasurer
 
Club Service
 
Community Service
 
Vocational Service
 
International Service
 
Rotary Foundation
 
Membership/Welfare
 
Youth Service
 
Environment
 
Immediate Past President
 
Sergeant-at-Arms
 
Minutes.
 
Attendance: Nooka reported that the footy tipping was ‘going electrical’, which he disapproved of.  He sought support from the members to keep going with pen and paper and then resigned when he didn’t receive it.  It certainly is an exciting time for the footy tipping.
 
 
Nooka recorded 21 members and one guest in attendance.  Our guest Louise Muggavin and the twenty-two members present were grateful to Nooka for his report. 
 
 
Once again this week, out of respect for Nooka, we have not taken his photo.  Instead we bring you an oil on canvas work we are calling 'Nooka goes electrical'.
 
 
Meal: Schnitzel, salad and chips.  Interestingly, schnitzels are served all around the world, but they vary greatly in different locations.  The typical Australian parmigiana style schnitzel with passata, cheese and sometimes ham is almost unique to Australia and New Zealand.
Our Sergeant David opened with an excellent joke about a priest, a doctor and a lawyer playing golf.  The joke was not fully appreciated by the lawn bowlers who listened to it being broadcast over the entire venue via the PA system.  Next time David try a joke about lawn bowls and see if they warn to that.  David then introduced our President, Bono.
Brendan reported;
  • The Trivia Night was a big success.  Thanks to Bishop Scott, the Fools on Stools, Glenn, all those who helped set up, Jon and Kelly, The Tickler and others who donated prizes, and of course Surf. 
  • The Relay for Life can collection was a bit disappointing with few recyclable containers and a lot of rubbish.  The Bonomatic 2000 did get the needed last trial before the May Races.
  • Brendan presented to the Rotary Clubs of Brighton and Brighton North.  The local DG was there, and it all went well. 
  • It was great to see both Robbo and Ron back and feeling better.
  • Paul Brophy from the Father Bob McGuire Foundation will present to us on March 11th
  • District Governor-elect Tonie Thiel met with Bono and is planning a three district District Conference for 2027. 
  • Footy tipping will be, in Nooka’s words, ‘going electrical’.  We will be tipping via the AFL tipping app.  Family members are welcome to join (for the entry fee) if they wish.
In other reports;
  • Robbo discussed the Bristol Stool Scale and its applications in modern medicine as we all tried to eat our lunch.  In all seriousness though, it sounds like Robbo has had a harrowing experience and we are very glad he out of hospital and on the mend.
  • Gerald reminded us we are assisting the Neil Porter Legacy next Tuesday at the dog track. 
Our guest speaker was Louise Muggavin, who Robbo recruited as a guest speaker while he was on death’s door in hospital.  You cannot question Robbo’s commitment to Rotary.
Louise is a former Rotary Exchange student who went to the Philippines in 1976.  She went to Iligan City in Mindanao.  She raised the $660 airfare herself by working during her school holidays.  Adjusted for inflation, that is the equivalent of about $5,250 today.  It is worth noting that the same flights today would cost less than $1,000. 
 
Louise noted that she stayed with very wealthy families, who had cooks, chauffeurs, and security guards.  The guards may have been helpful because she noted ‘Americans were being kidnapped’ at the time.  She attended the local university, which taught classes in English.  The experience developed a thirst for travel and Louise has since travelled all over the world.  She had hoped to return to Iligan City and visit old friend later this year, but the whole area is currently under a ‘do not travel’ advisory from DFAT. 
It was fascinating to hear from Louise about her exchange experience in a part of the world that most of us will never see.  We thank Louise for taking the time to present to us. 
Dillo then conducted an excellent fines session.  He was in Aldi recently and came across a collection of sports quiz questions that he described as ‘some of the worst questions you have ever seen’.  Naturally he thought of us and brought some of those questions in.  Dillo did tell a joke about Robbo, who liked tongue twisters, standing in court in front of the judge, who obligingly gave him a ‘tougher sentence’.  Don’t listen to them Dillo, I thought it was good.  Actually Dillo, I think what threw people off is that they were assuming Robbo was the defense attorney in your scenario, but you were assuming he was the defendant.
We had some fines from the floor before the barrel was drawn and Lew bagged the meal voucher on his birthday.  Happy birthday Lew!
Rotary Horse Racing report.
 
Last Thursday The Age ran an excellent piece by Danny Russell looking at the whole Sirileo Miss drug scandal.  Out of respect to Danny and The Age and their intellectual property I wont repeat what was written, but I encourage members who are interested and are Age subscribers to read the article. 
 
A few people have asked for my thoughts on the matter.  Although it is a change of pace for the Central Spoke, I thought I would share my thoughts for those who might be interested.  Obviously I cannot offer any insight or expertise around the legal process involved.  What I can do is give you more of a scientific, biological perspective on the saga.
 
Sirileao Miss tested positive to formestane and one of the breakdown products of formestane.  Formestane is a drug manufactured to treat some types of breast cancer.  It is a banned substance in sport because it can suppress oestrogen and increase testosterone production. 
 
Formestane is found in small amounts in humans because it is a natural breakdown product of androstenodione, a common prohormone that the body uses to produce testosterone and oestrogen.  Androstenedione can breakdown into Formestane through natural hydroxylation.  We know it exists in humans because this has been studied. 
 
We don’t know if formestane naturally exists in horses because it has never been studied.  However, we know horses produce androstenodione; it is produced in the ovaries of mares and is the main androgen produced by the adrenal cortex in mares like Sirileo Miss.  Given that horses contain hydroxylases (enzymes that produce hydroxylation), it would be reasonable to assume, in the absence of evidence, that some of the androstenodione in horses is probably breaking down into formestane as it does in humans. 
 
When WADA tests for formestane in human athletes they test for its presence but also do isotope mass spectrometry to determine if the formestane present is just endogenous (naturally occurring) is partially synthetic (i.e. administered to the athlete).  Racing Victoria does not do isotope mass spectrometry, they only test for the presence of formestane.  RV assumes that formestane does not occur naturally in horses.  No study has ever been done to determine if formestane does or does not occur naturally in horses.  For the reasons mentioned above, it would be surprising if it did not occur naturally in horses.
 
A simple explanation for the recent cluster of positive tests for formestane is that the testing methods have recently improved to the point that they are now sometimes detecting the small amounts of the formestane presumed to naturally occur in horses where previous testing could not.
 
Legally the trainers and Racing Victoria have decided that ‘the formestane found in Sirileo Miss was not naturally occurring’ is an ‘agreed fact’.  They have also agreed that the formestane was not deliberately administered by the trainers.  This would seem to only leave accidental contamination as an explanation. 
 
No materials or drugs linked to formestane administration was found during the investigation.  No mechanism for accidental contamination with formestane has been proposed.  Racing Victoria has not been able to provide any advice to trainers on how they may avoid accidental formestane contamination.
 
It may be legally an agreed fact that the formestane found in Sirileo Miss was not naturally occuring, but I would argue that this is by far the most likely explanation.  The obvious thing to do would be to fund a study to see if formestane occurs naturally in small amounts in horses before taking further action against trainers and owners following any positive test for formestane.
Ten Years Ago.
 
Ten years ago, we had Ricardo with us from Brasil.  After publishing a photo last week of Ciao going full Clive Bray on a sheep, it would be remiss of us not to publish this photo of Ricardo operating the business end of a cow.
 
Our Club Fundraiser 2023 - every hand on deck!
Building on 2021-2023 - Supporting ROMP
Date TBC
Send contributions to;
 
bulletin.warrnamboolcentral@gmail.com
Subscribe to Bulletin
Subscribe to our eBulletin and stay up to date on the latest news and events.
Check out the latest Rotary International News here: www.rotary.org/en